About one in six people in the US have gotten used to commanding their Amazon Echo or Google Home with voice. But in China, where consumers seem quick to adopt new technology like mobile payment, smart speakers still don’t have much appeal.

In 2017, US consumers bought 25 million smart speakers. But in China, they bought just 350,000.

To put that number into context, the country has over 100 smart speaker developers (including all of the tech giants) and China’s 772 million internet users, according to the 2018 China Internet Report -- and yet they’re seemingly not interested in smart speakers.

Baidu has stopped producing its stylish and pricey Raven H, which was highly praised when revealed at CES in January. (Picture: Raven H)

JD.com and Xiaomi accounted for 70% of all smart speakers sold in China last year, the report says, and Alibaba took 15%.

(Abacus is a unit of the South China Morning Post, which is owned by Alibaba.)

One reason could be that voice recognition in the Chinese language is still not as mature as in English, a Gartner analyst told Bloomberg last year.

Others suggest Chinese consumers may not be as eager to try new technology as first thought. “Chinese are more conservative in living situation, lifestyle and behavior, which has an influence on smart speaker adoption,” says Sophie Pan, senior analyst at IDC Beijing.

Another problem might be that there’s too much fragmentation -- there isn’t a single winner to rally around.

Chinese internet companies want to use smart speakers to keep users within their own ecosystems, but with no winner in the smart home market yet and companies competing over users, it’s hard to find a smart speaker that’s compatible with most internet services. Some say that for Chinese consumers, most smart speakers end up being used as bluetooth speakers.

Despite all that, some still predict that smart speakers will be the next big thing for consumers in China.

“People (in China) are used to interacting with devices through the screens, but talking to them is the next generation way of interaction,” said IDC’s Pan.

“2016 was the year of drones, and last year we saw a boom in augmented and virtual reality,” IDC analyst Antonio Want told the South China Morning Post, “2018 is going to be the year of smart speakers.”